Adriana is reunited with Duke after sneaking into the house. Michael warns Natalie if she keeps trying to get John back he's going to end up breaking her heart. Hayes denies claims that he is The Killing Club murderer. Carlo is back and Asa wants Carlo to kill Blair. Evangeline overhears Natalie talking to Michael about John saying he loved her when he rescued her from The Killing Club murderer. Marcie believes that Hayes isn't The Killing Club murderer.